Will Rust kill Python for Data Engineers? If you only came here to know this, my answer is no. Betteridge’s Law strikes again!
But then again, you have to ask: was Python made for Data Engineering in the first place?
What is Rust?
Former Mozilla employee Graydon Hoare initially created Rust as a personal project. The first stable release, Rust 1.0 was released on May 15, 2015. Rust is a multi-paradigm programming language that supports imperative procedural, concurrent actor, object-oriented and pure functional styles, supporting generic programming and metaprogramming statically and dynamically.
The goal of Rust is to be a good programming language for creating highly concurrent, safe, and performant systems.
What Is Unique about Rust?
Rust solves pain points from other programming languages with minimal downsides. With Rust being a compiled programming language, strong type and system checks are enforced during compile-time—meaning pre-runtime! Unlike Python’s interpreted way, most errors only surface during the coding phase. It can be frustrating to fight every single mistake before being able to test or run a quick script, but at the same time, a prominent feature like the compiler is much faster at finding bugs than me. Additionally, the Rust community puts a lot of effort into making the error messages super informative.
Why Rust for Data Engineers?
When you write any code, the goal is that the code doesn’t break during the weekend or at night when you sleep. Rust will show you errors and improvements while coding and fails as much as possible at compile-time, which is less costly than later in production at run-time.
The go-to language for data engineers is Python, which isn’t the most robust or safe language, as many engineers working with data will agree. Rust’s developer experience goes much further than just offering a language specification and a compiler; many aspects of creating and maintaining production-quality software are treated as first-class citizens in the Rust ecosystem
What Rust Does Well
Python is dynamically typed (with only recent support for type hints) and requires writing extensive tests to catch these costly errors. But that takes a lot of time, and you must foresee all potential errors to write a test for it.
Rust is the opposite; it forces you to define types (or does it implicitly with type inference) and enforces them. This does not obsolete testing of course, but for example, the rust compiler will analyze e.g. borrow checking, and does things to your code that other compilers don’t do—check out rust-analyzer for bringing them into your IDE of choice. This makes it very good for data engineers as we have many moving parts such as incoming data sets that we do not control. Defining expectations with data types and having vigorous checks at coding and compile time will prevent many errors.
Less relevant for data engineers, but super helpful: speed. Rust, as a compiled language, is super fast at run-time. To many, Rust is primarily an alternative to other systems programming languages, like C or C++. But you don’t need a systems use case to use a systems language, as both Vercel and Crowdstrike are noticing.
Another one is integrations. With data pipelines being the glue code in most cases, connecting otherwise foreign systems, Rust almost runs platform agnostic. Rust makes it easy to integrate and communicate with other languages through a so-called foreign function interface (FFI). The FFI provides a zero-cost abstraction where function calls between Rust and C have identical performance to C function calls. Rust can be called easily from C, Python, Ruby, and vice-versa. Find more on Rust Once, Run Everywhere.
A less technical but still important element is to love or have fun, enjoying your programming language. Rust is a more complex language to learn, but it was the most loved technology for seven years (2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016) in a row on the Stack Overflow survey:
Besides the love, it’s also rising in awareness of different trends such as Google Trend, one from 2019 Ranking on GitHub, or the StackOverflow below:
Interesting Open-Source Rust Projects
The language is always only as good as its community. Let’s look at some of the existing open-source tools and frameworks built in and around Rust:
- DataFusion based on Apache Arrow: Apache Arrow DataFusion SQL Query Engine similar to Spark
- Polars: It’s a faster Pandas. Probably going to compete with DuckDB (?)
- Delta Lake Rust: A native Rust library for Delta Lake, with bindings into Python and Ruby
- Cube: Headless BI for Building Data Applications
- Written mostly in Rust, Cube’s data processing and storage are based on the Arrow DataFusion query execution framework, which uses Apache Arrow as its in-memory format. Especially the core of Cube, the cache layer called Cube Store is 100% built-in Rust
- Vector.dev: A high-performance observability data pipeline for pulling system data (logs, metadata)
- ROAPI: Create full-fledged APIs for slowly moving datasets without writing a single line of code
- Meilisearch: Lightning Fast, Ultra Relevant, and Typo-Tolerant search engine
- Tantivy: A full-text search engine library
- PRQL: Pipelined Relational Query Language for transforming data
- Many more; please let me know of any
Less relevant to data engineering, but still cool:
- Deno: This is a fast Node.js version
- Tauri: Tauri is a framework for building tiny, blazingly fast binaries for all major desktop platforms
- Yew: A modern Rust framework for creating multi-threaded front-end web apps with WebAssembly.
Rust vs. Python
The downside of Rust, the learning curve is much higher than other languages, such as Python. That’s why most Rust programs in data engineering will have a Python wrapper for integrating it into any Python data pipelines for a long time. It’s also a shift from an interpreted language such as Python to a more Functional Language (FP) style, which Rust certainly supports.
What makes Python popular right now:
- It’s old
- It’s beginner-friendly
- It’s versatile
The downsides of Python:
- Speed / Multithreading
- Mobile Development
- Runtime Errors
Check more on Why Python is not the programming language of the future or a small Twitter poll if Rust is suited for data engineering.
Other Recent Programming Languages
Newer programming languages follow the functional programming approach. New functional programming languages started, such as Scala with Akka, Elixir, or multi-paradigm programming languages such as Julia, Kotlin (a fastest-growing language since Google made it default for Android development), and Rust.
GoLang seems to be a good compiled programming language usedin DevOps.
Elixir has servers monitoring data pipelines and re-tries included in the language; no framework is needed. It makes an excellent fit for data engineering and would replace parts of the Data Orchestrators.
Rust as a Primary Language?
Let’s see an example of a modern data pipeline integrating with Airbyte, dbt, and some ML models in Python.
As we typically load data into a data frame and transform or add some business logic within our data pipelines. This could be done efficiently with Rust and Apache Arrow, and DataFusion, which is type-safe, and a good ecosystem. Time will tell.
Will Rust Be the Programming Language for Data Engineers?
Rust is a multi-use language and gets the job done for many problems of a data engineer. But the data engineering space is dominated by Python (and SQL) and will stay that way for the foreseeable future. There is no “until people fully move into Rust”. It’s hard to express how many tools and frameworks are written in Python to interoperate with other Python tools. It’s pretty hard to imagine that inertia changing substantially in the next decade.
The Rust projects we have seen above are excellent and will continue to grow for vital and core components, but for them to be helpful for the average data engineer. What was once supposed to be Scala will now be Rust —a backend tooling language to do tasks that need fast and well-maintained code, including a Python wrapper on top.
Writing libraries in Rust feels more like writing long-term infrastructure than writing in higher-level languages such as Python, Java, or the JVM.
What do you think? What is your take on Rust for data engineers?
Resources to Learn More on the Topic
Suppose you want to be up and running within minutes. Karim Jedda has an article, carefully exploring the Rust programming ecosystem as a 10+ years Python developer, checking how to do everyday programming tasks and what the tooling looks like. Shared Services of Canada did a hands-on example with Rust converting raw archive files into JSON for data analysis. Or Mehdi Ouazza’s article where he debates the Battle for Data Engineer’s Favorite Programming Language.
Learning Rust has many excellent resources. A half-hour to learn Rust, The Rust Book, Rust By Example, Read Rust, or This Week In Rust.
Or Learning Rust with different kinds of formats:
Or do you want to get hands-on and search for an example project? How about building an Airbyte Delta Lake Destination (Python interface) with delta-rs?
Originally published at Airbyte.com